We Sent A Load Of Journalists And PRs On A Blind Date. Here’s What Happened…

Yes, we know what you’re thinking. The people who fill your inboxes with daily press releases probably aren’t the first people you think to head on a blind date with. If, of course, picking someone for a blind date didn’t completely defeat the point of the encounter.

But, if you strip it back to basics, the relationship between journalists and PRs should be an easy one – one is a group of people is looking for stories and the other come armed with story ideas ready to go. Almost every journalist will need to work with PRs at some point in your career – whether you’re looking for a company response, access to a celebrity interview, or some exclusive story information, more often than not, they’re the people to go to.

In short, working out how to get the best out of your relationships with PRs is a worthwhile investment. So, how to get it right? Well, in conjunction with our pals at ResponseSource, we decided the best thing to do would be to just throw everyone in a room together to work it out. So, here’s what happened when we sent three journalists and three PRs on some speed dates. And yes, we provided the Deliveroo.

Were You Surprised By Anything The Journalists/PRs Told You About Their Job?

Amy Borrett, Data Journalist at the New Statesman: Not especially, although I was surprised at the breadth of companies that they worked with.

Claire Beaumont, Head of PR & Content at Igniyte: It’s always really interesting to get first hand accounts from journalists about how they’re working in the industry at the moment, and how things have changed and evolved.

Vanese Maddix, freelance journalist: Not necessarily, however, I’m used to connecting with PRs with beauty clients, so it was nice to connect with PRs with a whole range of clients not necessarily in my field.

“I was surprised to hear from one journalist that they sometimes find it difficult to get high quality comment turned around quickly from PRs.”

Lee Simpson

Allie Nawrat, journalist at UNLEASH: Not so much. I have quite a few friends that work in PR so I am pretty clued into how journalism differs and what us journalists can do to make their lives easier! (AKA replying to emails and actually being friendly!)

Lee Simpson, account director at Fourth Day PR: I was surprised to hear from one journalist that they sometimes find it difficult to get high quality comment for their features turned around quickly from PRs. It made me realise that quality and speed are absolutely vital.

Finbarr Toesland, freelance journalist: Not really, but it was interesting to hear about the pressures facing PRs as they deal with requests from journalists at the same time as keeping their clients happy.

Victoria Heywood, Communications Officer at Guide Dogs: Not really, as I myself have been a journalist before. It was a bit surprising to have some journalists from some very niche subjects or with a mostly international audience. With them we had a bit of struggle to work out how we could work together in the future as our interests/needs didn’t really overlap. Hopefully as this event expands you’ll be able to ‘matchmake’ people more?

ResponseSource – The Industry’s Worst Kept Secret?

Looking for case studies, expert comment, interviews or products to review? ResponseSource’s Journalist Enquiry Service connects you with thousands of PRs from all sectors, saving you hours of research and helping you to meet your deadline.

It’s completely free to use and can provide results in minutes, direct to your inbox. Find out more and try it here.

What Do You Think People Misunderstand About PR/Journalism?

Amy: I think there is a lot of misunderstanding around what data journalists do, especially around the nature of the data that we need to stand up a good story.

Claire: People tend to misunderstand about what is involved in PR, it could be something simple like not knowing what is involved, or what our days look like from day to day. I always try and explain to people that I manage brands (personal or business) and that involves so many different things, PRs always have a lot of plates spinning in the air.

Vanese: I think sometimes people assume that if you work in journalism that you get to call the shots about absolutely everything, like automatically getting to decide which publications you want to write for, which isn’t true. Even if you work in-house for a publication, you still have to pitch your ideas and a pitch is not always picked up the first time around.

“I think a lot of people think that it is national newspapers or bust – like they should only be focused on getting stories into nationals.”

Allie Nawrat

Allie: I think a lot of people think that it is national newspapers or bust – like they should only be focused on getting stories into nationals. But actually, in terms of business, you want potential clients to read the stories, you are often better to get the story into a smaller B2B publication with knowledgeable sector-specific journalists.

I think PRs often get it more – but the general public don’t really get the breadth and depth of the media industry and that it is much more than the Daily Mail, Guardian and BBC.

Lee: PRs seem to get the most bashing on social media for starting emails with ‘Hi, hope you’re well’ and pitching irrelevant stories to journalists. So, there’s perhaps a common misconception that PRs are blithely pitching their clients in for things when in reality, in my experience, that couldn’t be further from the truth. Most of us are just being nice and trying do the best work we can for our clients!

Finbarr: I don’t think many people are aware of the process in which articles are created. From pitching, speaking to sources to editing, the general public only see the ‘finished product’ and a lack of transparency around the creation process needs to be addressed so there is more trust in journalism.

Victoria: That anyone could do it and it’s not a real profession or skill!

If You Could Change One Thing About Journalists/PRs What Would It Be And Why?

Amy: I think I would like to receive more tailored pitches that fall within my beat. Too often PRs reach out with pitches and companies that are quite clearly outside of the areas that I cover.

Claire: I appreciate that journalists are busy, but even something simple like a one-word email saying no to pitches would be so helpful. Pitches often go into the ether and I don’t want to bug by following up on something they don’t feel is right for them at the time.

Vanese: I think PRs are great and amazing at what they do. If I could change one thing it would probably be for PRs and Journalists to build an even deeper bond. I’ve had some really great 1-1 Zoom sessions with PRs where we’ll have a virtual coffee and get to know each other better.

“Even something simple like a one-world email saying no to pitches would be so helpful.”

Claire Beaumont

Allie: Constant following up, especially on the phone. Journalists are often at the whim of editors – so even if they wanted to cover a story, they often can’t – so not nice to be made to feel bad for not covering something.

I also think being insistent on phone calls or video interviews – sometimes email questions suffice and save us journalists a lot of time (transcribing is a real time waster for us!).

Lee: It would be useful to receive feedback on stories that aren’t hitting the mark. That way we can offer the most value as possible to each other and nobody needs to waste too much time.

Finbarr: It would be great if PRs got in touch with more tailored pitches, rather than simply pitch broad topics that I would never cover, which wastes time for both the PR and journalist.

Victoria: I don’t love churnalism/clickbait that is about causing division and driving revenue. It’s a shame the economics of journalism have changed so much.

Hopefully You’ve Made Some Professional Connections, Do You Think You’ll Stay In Touch?

Amy: I can definitely see fruitful collaborations with some of the PRs in the future.

Claire: I’m hoping so, I think the matches that were chosen were really good, and I’m looking forward to working together on future projects.

Vanese: For sure, everyone I spoke to was super lovely. There was a whole heap of giggles and it was lovely to learn about upcoming projects from the PRs which I’m looking forward to seeing pan out.

Allie: Definitely! I have already connected with a few of the PRs on social media and will hopefully get a few good stories out of it.

Lee: Absolutely! We have already connected on LinkedIn and Twitter. Maybe you could go full Cilla Black and revisit this in a year to see how our relationships have flourished.

Finbarr: Yes, I intend to keep in touch with a few of the PRs and will reach out to them when an article I’m working on needs expert commentary.

Victoria: I hope so, yes!

This article and speed dating was put together in collaboration with our 2021 sponsors ResponseSource. If you’re looking for expert comment and interviews in a flash, their journalist enquiry service can connect you with the right people almost instantly. Oh, and it’s free.